Best Buy Marketplace: Why Is Succeeding Where Couldn’t

In this article, we will compare with and take a look at the strategies that has acquired to succeed in an ever-growing eCommerce space.

Let’s learn more about the Best Buy Marketplace.

What is

Announced in May 2016, Best Buy’s Marketplace released the following official press release:

Canadians will soon find online and mobile shopping even easier with Best Buy Canada through better availability of the latest and greatest products, the peace of mind that comes with knowing when a package is going to arrive and the access to an even larger product assortment on through a new ‘Marketplace’ for other Canadian retailers.

Through our ‘Delivery Promise’ initiative, our ability to turn each of our 192 stores into online warehouses and the addition of a ‘Marketplace,’ it will be easier than ever for customers to search for, find and receive the products they want.

But did you know that had an American cousin that failed? Instead of this fact being a blemish on the Canadian site, it’s a point of positivity. was able to examine and evaluate what led to the .com’s demise. As a result, it has created a highly effective marketplace that retailers across North America are flocking to.

What Is The Secret Behind’s Strategy?

Data integration and a solid eCommerce marketplace platform are the key factors of’s successful strategy.

Keep reading to find out more about how has been rising from the ashes of Don’t forget to subscribe to VL’s newsletter to be the first to know when VL OMNI launches content like our popular How-To Guide!

how-to-guides-best-buy Best Buy Marketplace How-To Guide.

Why Is Succeeding Where Couldn’t’s Marketplace was a well-intentioned but problem-riddled execution of what was meant to be a strategic expansion of product offerings the Best Buy brand carried online. Instead, unsuitable and inflexible cornerstone applications combined with a lack of a scalable integration strategy and a slew of various communication issues ultimately sank the American Best Buy Marketplace in a little over 5 years.

Interestingly, — the Canadian version of the American marketplace — launched only months before the .com marketplace threw in the towel on February 24th, 2016. The Marketplace officially launched just in time to reap the rewards of the 2015 holiday season; a highly strategic move. Fighting to set their own reputation apart from their now-failed American iteration, the Canadian Best Buy Marketplace took a gamble launching during the busy holiday season: they’d either prove that they’ve built a better machine on the lessons of, or would unceremoniously put themselves on the same path to eventual destruction.

Learning From the Lessons of

The Canadian Best Buy Marketplace knew full well the troubles that the American Marketplace was facing likely well before the project was started. Also launching during the holiday season, but five years sooner in 2011, the American Best Buy Marketplace was riddled with issues fairly quickly. Poor planning and an apparent lack of strategies to manage various vendor needs, touch points, and communication methods gave rise to three broad factors that eventually sunk the American Marketplace:

  • Inconsistent Pricing
  • Conflicting Return Policies
  • Poor Revenue


Customers quickly became dissatisfied with the marketplace, leaving the website for competitors like Amazon and eBay where the customer experience met or exceeded consumer expectations. From the start, Best Buy’s American Marketplace employed sub-par strategies, ultimately creating a digital mess on the consumer-facing side of the site. Prices were often inconsistent with the bricks-and-mortar locations and the online channel, leaving customers confused and feeling cheated.

With hundreds of retailers selling into the marketplace, failed to account for the many types of vendors trying to integrate into the marketplace. A lack of procedures, policies, operating frameworks, and data translation and transmission architecture essentially created a free-for-all for retailers seeking to update product information and pricing on the portal.

Best Buy’s American Marketplace also failed to consider and standardize the return policies of all of the retailers selling on the marketplace with those of Best Buy. Imagine the frustration of customers: pricing was already inconsistent, and now returning their items was not the straightforward process customers were used to with the Best Buy bricks-and-mortar stores. Unsurprisingly, this led to a free fall in customer confidence for the marketplace, plummeting profits, and eventually led to its demise.

Canada’s Best Buy Marketplace’s launch overlapped the American Marketplace’s slow slide into oblivion by quite a few months. The Canadian iteration had plenty of data on the shortcomings of its American counterpart, making their launch the prime opportunity to redeem the Best Buy Marketplace model while creating a new and more robust marketplace for the consumer electronics space.

Best Buy Marketplace of Cosmo Music - the musical instrument superstore items available on Best Buy Marketplace

Why Is The Best Buy Marketplace So Special? started from the absolute bottom: they started building their marketplace using the well-known system from France, Mirakl. Mirakl is well known for its eCommerce marketplace solutions with major European retailers. Highly reliable and designed to fit the needs of, the Canadian Marketplace simply has great bones. also created a rigorous set of standards for potential sellers to adhere to. Communication standards for data transmission and translation both to and from the marketplace have the bar set high for sellers and favors those who have the ability to have their data and applications fully integrated into the marketplace’s back end. And has been doing extremely well with both consumers and retailers. Many product categories are under-represented in the marketplace today, creating a distinct blue ocean competitive advantage for those retailers that can meet the marketplace’s rigorous expectations and be early adopters. The Marketplace is attracting retailers from across North America and is in high demand!

The Future of has completely freed itself of any hurdles or shortcomings that existed in the defunct American marketplace. Through careful evaluation of, the Canadian iteration has approached the problem of creating a robust eCommerce marketplace ecosystem for buyers and sellers with a solid data integration strategy (and thus, communication standards) at the heart. is poised to corner the online market for consumer electronics and more and is currently in the process of expanding in under-represented marketplace categories.

Thinking of adopting Best Buy’s Canadian Marketplace into your omnichannel mix? VL has partnered with the Canadian Best Buy Marketplace to help their retailers meet and exceed the data integration and communication standards set out by the portal. We have already helped many of our customers seamlessly onboard with!

Interested in learning more?

best buy how to sell guideCheck out our Best Buy Marketplace How-To Guide



VL OMNI Newsletter signup

Subscribe to VL OMNI

Get expert advice, resources, and industry news for your growing ecommerce store delivered to your inbox